Welcome to Four Star Pizza
Four Star Pizza, located at 334 Seneca St, Oil City, PA, offers a delightful range of pizzas and subs, making it a standout in the local food scene. Customers rave about the freshness and quality of their offerings, with favorites like the 12-inch turkey sub and various pizzas drawing high praise. The friendly service enhances the experience, with staff dedicated to ensuring satisfaction. While some reviews mention occasional order mix-ups, the recent turnaround in management has improved consistency and service quality. Whether you're a local like Wil Logsdon or traveling from afar, Four Star Pizza promises a delicious meal worth the trip.
-
334 Seneca St, Oil City, PA 16301, United States Hotline: +1 814-676-5600
Welcome to the culinary haven of Four Star Pizza, located at
334 Seneca St, Oil City, PA 16301, United States. This establishment has become a beloved choice for pizza and subs in the community, with many patrons singing its praises. From the very first bite, it’s clear that Four Star Pizza goes above and beyond to deliver an exceptional dining experience.Customers like Wil Logsdon mention a delightful little family rivalry, with his wife passionately choosing Four Star over other chains. Meanwhile, Frank S humorously rates the pizzeria as “more like 5 Star” for its savory dishes, especially highlighting the remarkable 12-inch turkey sub. Although his sub may have been "a little heavy on Italian dressing," it demonstrates the restaurant's focus on delivering quality flavors, even as personal preferences vary.
Speed and service are also where Four Star Pizza shines. Cheryl Ames had her pizza and grilled chicken salad prepared within a mere 15 minutes, while Crystal Chiaramonte was pleasantly surprised by the generous size of her small pizza. The warm, attentive staff consistently enhance the experience, even going out of their way to correct issues. One review highlights a moment of kindness when a gentle employee adjusted an order to the customer's preference, illustrating a commendable level of customer care.
Despite facing some management hurdles in the past, recent reviewers such as Hyper Flexx indicate that Four Star Pizza has made significant improvements, transforming potential criticisms into a glowing endorsement. The friendly and professional staff have made repeat visits worth it, proving their commitment to enhancing patron satisfaction.
In addition to scrumptious subs and pizzas—where the fresh ingredients are the stars of the show—patrons rave about the delightful combinations offered. From classic options to inventive takes on beloved favorites, there’s something to suit every taste. As April J Vearnon noted, the pizza emerges hot and just as ordered, a testament to their dedication to customer satisfaction right from the oven.
It’s not just the delightful dishes that encourage a return visit; it’s the warm atmosphere fostered by the staff. With every bite, Four Star Pizza not only feeds the hunger but also leaves a lasting impression. As a reviewer myself, I'm eager to explore more of their offerings and immerse myself in the cozy vibe this Oil City gem exudes.
If you're in the area or traveling from afar, give Four Star Pizza a try. It’s more than just a meal—it’s an invitation to savor food made with heart and craft. With every visit, you might find a new favorite dish or create a treasured memory with loved ones. Don’t hesitate to reach out for orders at +1 814-676-5600 and experience the charm of Four Star Pizza for yourself.
I like Dominoes but my wife is obsessed with 4 star so guess where we usually order from.
4 Star Pizza is more like 5 Star lol. I got the 12 inch Turkey sub and it was great. A little heavy on Italian dressing but some people may have wanted more so it's just a personal preference. Some slices of pizza ready to go like some pizzerias do would have been nice but it's better fresh.
We stopped at the Oil City store on our way home and ordered pizza and salad. It was ready in 15 minutes. The pizza was very good and the grilled chicken salad was delicious. I will definitely have that again. Also, the girl who waited on me was very friendly and helpful.
We got a small pizza and half a sub. Pizza was bigger than what we thought which was nice. My sub was warm and I wanted a cold sub, I went in and the sweet gentleman behind the counter fixed it. He was very kind! Will be coming here again next time we're in town!
some of the best pizza I've had, in the best location i've ever been. not even exaggerating
Pizza and subs are great... IF you can get them the way you ORDERED.. GOOD LUCK WITH THAT! Don't even bother calling in to complain if they got it WRONG AGAIN. The manager is the WORST EVER! He told me "oh well"! I told him I was reporting him. The fact that he still has a job there only shows how little they care about my money. I order from Pizza Hut now. Great staff and great service for a great price! Bye bye Poor Star! —-EDIT—- so for the past few months, the wife and I have decided to give this establishment another try. I am always for upgrading and updating my reviews. Four-star has really turned itself around since the last time I posted my review. Prior to this edit we’ve had so much trouble with four-star that I gave up on them all together. The place was being ran poorly, by a manager who could care less about the customers. I am happy to report that this has all changed! I have made well over 20 different orders testing each one to see how they do. There has been a few mistakes, but nothing serious. The staff are all very friendly, And professional. I have not had to interact with a manager at all. If my order was incorrect, or a mistake was made, it has been corrected every time without question. All I can say is keep up the great work Four-star! Your work is not going unnoticed! If I had one complaint that the general manager would take note of... It would be too please use fresh lettuce every day with every order. You can tell when lettuce has been sitting in the cooler overnight, it ruins the order. I have to scrape the lettuce off into the garbage just to enjoy my meal. Other than that you’re doing a great job at running this place please keep up the great work!
Wish they didn’t take out the Franklin location bc I used to go right by there about 6/8 times a year and stop in. Now I prob will only stop once a year since oil city location is much further away. I travel about an hour to get the pizza, I won’t go further.
Yesterday I ordered a club sub add a medium extra cheese pizza it was absolutely amazing the first time in a long time I got a pizza that was hot it was just the way I asked for it and the subs are always on point I couldn't say that I haven't had a bad experience there but most of my experiences with this store and Oil City have been almost perfect keep up the good work